Sephardic Shock: New update to FTDNA’s MyOrigin

FTDNA has rolled out the long-awaited update to their MyOrigins ethnicity estimator–and it includes Sephardic in the reference panel! I was shocked to see such a high percentage of Sephardic in my results, which had merely been suggested by GEDmatch before, but in a smaller amount. Disappointingly, I found some changes in other catagories that raised an eyebrow. I have to question whether this Sephardic component can be considered accurate.

I would love to hear your thoughts on whether the accuracy of FTDNA’s MyOrigins has improved with their new version. Weigh in on the comments section below! 


I got excited when I saw the 11% Sephardic component. GEDmatch had suggested there was significant Sephardic ancestry in my Ashkenazi grandfather. This family line has y-DNA tested as being Mizrahi in origin, surprisingly. Haplogroup R-M124 very well could have entered Europe through Sephardic lands like Roman Italy and Spain, based on the historical evidence.

Then I saw they had me as 0% Western European–before I was 42%, and Ancestry has me at 48%. The entire category has disappeared in the updated results. This is an issue because I have lots of Western European ancestors in my tree, including some relatively recent immigration from Pomerania, Germany.
Furthermore, they clocked me in at almost 1/4 Southeastern European (Greece, Italy, Balkan). I have an extensive tree with no know ancestry from any of these regions. This is also clearly problematic.

However, some results appear to have genuinely improved with the new update. 

My Scandinavian used to be grossly underestimated at 2%, and is now 17%. This is more in line with my tree, having recent immigration from Norway.

Eastern European went from 21% to 7%. This is probably also more accurate.

Additionally, the increased British Isles checks out compared to what I know about my tree. I have recent immigration from Lincolnshire, England on one branch. Prior to the update, FTDNA had me at 0% British Isles.

Because of the total disappearance of Western European when it should be close to 50%, and the surprise large amount of Southeastern European, I’m concerned about how reliable these results are. This makes me question the validity of the Sephardic result along with it. As they say, percentages must always be taken with a grain of salt. In this case, a large grain indeed.
Have you noticed any major changes to your results? 

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Sephardic Shock: New update to FTDNA’s MyOrigin

  1. As I said in my comment on your Facebook post, mine has improved! Finally picking up close to 100% British Isles like the paper trail on all my kits. Weird that the trace regions are so different though. The biggest shocker with the trace regions is that they’ve added 6% Jewish Diaspora to my mum’s test, which I suppose could be possible since I haven’t had any cousin matches on her paternal line but still a massive shock since it hasn’t come up with any other testing companies and doesn’t reflect the known trail.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. My old results had 33% British Isles, and 38% Scandinavia. This made sense as I have grandparents from both Norway and Scotland. The new algorithm gave only 18% British Isles, 0% Scandinavia and added 78% West and Central European. It also added ‘noise’ from Central America and Oceania. My wife had all of her 15% Scandinavian removed (she is Swedish by surname), and was replaced with West/Central European. Her Iberian (Sephardic?) was replaced with European Jewish at 2%.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. My previous results gave my mother Ashkenazi DNA for 10% (I had 8%) and now it disappears in mother’s results, and I have 2% now only 🙂 Funny. Unless, there was very small Ashkenazi in my father’s ancestry, and together with mother’s combined into my 2%.

    PS: Thanks for this post, I referred to my as additional resource.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s